top of page
  • Writer's pictureAmi Cooper

The Great Debate: Acrylic vs. Gel Nails

So every couple of years, the subject of acrylics, gels, gel polish, and dip manicures makes the rounds of whether or not they are good or bad services. I am asked this a lot by new clients, returning clients, and even other nail professionals deciding on what to specialize in. The real issue is not the services but the person doing the services and their skill and level of proper training and application. In every industry, you have those that truly care about what they are doing and want to always do their best. And then you have those that just want to make a buck and go about their day. And lately, it seems as though in the nail industry, it's about 50/50. As techs, we can never have too much education or too much knowledge about the industry. And as consumers, you can never ask too many questions about services, or products. I hope to help clear up some questions but as always, ask away, because the more honest knowledge the public has as clients and we as nail techs can provide, the better!


So let's break down the services that most commonly come into question about what are good or bad for nails:


Acrylics, Dip Powder (SNS),

Acrylic is Dip Powder, Dip Powder is Acrylic. Yes, you read that right. THEY ARE THE SAME. Traditional Acrylic nails are a nail enhancement that has been around for decades! They are artificial enhancements applied to natural nails or over a plastic tip to achieve a longer and more durable appearance.  The nails are created by combining a liquid monomer with a powder polymer to form a strong, durable coating over the natural nails.  The acrylic mixture hardens through a process called polymerization, and air-dries without the need for UV light.

Dip nails or SNS (Signature Nail Systems, a brand of dipping powder) as many know them, is the process of dipping, (or some techs pour the powder over) the nail into the acrylic powder and then coating them with a liquid resin (activator) that hardens the powder in the same way as traditional acrylic.

The "Good"

Durability: They are known for their strength and durability. They can withstand everyday activities better than most natural nails.

Versatility: They can be customized in terms of length, shape, and color. They provide a versatile canvas for various nail art designs.

Repairable: If the acrylic on the nail breaks or gets damaged, it can often be repaired easily at a salon.

Lengthening: They are a popular choice for individuals who want to lengthen their nails or who are nail biters and want to grow out their natural nails.

The "Bad"

Risk of Damage: Incorrect application, improper removal, or over exposure of product can lead to damage to the natural nails. This may include thinning, weakening, or even fungal infections if NOT applied or removed properly.

Chemical Odor: The process of applying acrylic nails involves the use of chemicals, which can produce an odor. Some individuals may find this unpleasant. THE USE OF MMA PRODUCTS IN THE USA IS ILLEGAL

Allergies: Some people may be sensitive or allergic to the chemicals used in acrylic nail products, leading to skin irritation or allergic reactions. Acrylics, gels, hard gel, dip powder are all acrylate based products, that when done incorrectly or an over exposure to skin can cause an

allergy.


Gel Nails (ie, Gel Polish, Hard Gels, Rubber Base Gels, Builder In A Bottle BIAB)

Gels are a service that requires the use of an LED or UV light to cure and harden the product. It creates a flexible and strong base for the natural nail to be protected and to help with growth. Gel polish is the thinnest of the gel type products and is the most popular for clients looking to just have a coating of color over their natural nails or toes. If applied correctly, you can wear a color for up to 4 weeks. Also they designed to be soaked off.

Rubber bases have become popular in the last couple years and are similar to gel polish in that they are thin and a soak off gel. Rubber bases tend to be much for flexible and provide great foundation for clients with really weak nails that need to build back some strength.

Hard gel and Builder in a bottle (BIAB) gels are essentially that same thing in that they are both designed to add strength and structure to the nails. However, where hard gels are one product to build layers, BIAB gels are often considered an all-in-one product that combines the functions of a base coat, builder gel, and topcoat. They are designed for natural nail overlays and strengthening without necessarily adding length. Again, when deciding, all types of gels have their merits, and the choice depends on the desired outcome and personal preference of the user.

The "Good"

Long-Lasting:

  • Gel nails are known for their durability and longevity. They typically last longer than traditional nail polish without chipping.

Quick Drying:

  • Gel nails cure quickly under UV or LED lamps, allowing for a faster and more efficient application process compared to traditional polish.

Versatility:

  • Gel nails come in a wide range of colors and finishes, including glossy, matte, and glitter options. This allows for a variety of creative and customizable nail designs.

Natural Look:

  • When applied correctly, gel nails can provide a natural and polished appearance. They are also thinner than some other artificial nail options, offering a more realistic feel.

The "Bad"

Professional Application:

  • While DIY kits are available, achieving optimal results with gel nails often requires professional application. Improper application can lead to issues like lifting and peeling.

Removal Process:

  • Removing gel nails at home can be challenging, and improper removal can damage the natural nails. It often involves soaking the nails in acetone, which may cause dryness and weaken the nails.

Cost:

  • Professional gel nail applications can be more expensive than traditional manicures or even acrylic nails. Additionally, the cost of UV or LED lamps for home use can contribute to the overall expense.

Risk of Damage:

  • If not applied or removed properly, gel nails can lead to damage such as thinning, peeling, or brittleness of natural nails. It's important to follow proper application and removal procedures to minimize these risks.

Allergic Reactions:

  • Some individuals may develop allergic reactions to the chemicals present in gel nail products. It's advisable to do a patch test before full application, especially for those with sensitive skin.


With everything that hits social media, the information that is put out is both correct and incorrect, and there is never a simple answer. However, in this case the first and most important answer is this; Going to a licensed nail tech, that uses quality legal products (NO MMA), does meticulous safe manicuring, and proper prep and application is what separates “good” nails from “bad” nails. And that goes for ANY service you are getting.

The second most important thing to do when going to ANYONE to get your nails or even a pedicure, is to ask questions! A quality nail tech, that’s legally licensed, is required to always have MSDS sheets for their products. They should also be able to tell you what is in their products, and where they came from. Keeping the integrity and health of your nails is what responsible nail techs do, regardless of the type of service you're having done.

And before you ask, no, one service type is not better than another. It’s all a matter of what someone is looking for, and whatever works BEST for YOUR nails!!


With every blog, my goal is to give a little insight into some of the topics and questions that come my way through clients or sent to me through social media. If you have any questions about this or any other topic, or want to know more information about the services I offer, please always feel free to contact me directly at paisleynailstudiollc@gmail.com



I AM NOT A DOCTOR OR MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL


The content provided by/of Amelia Cooper Hannon or Paisley Nail Studio LLC either through this website, Amelia Cooper or Paisley Nail Studio LLC social media pages, or any other materials distributed by Amelia Cooper or Paisley Nail Studio LLC is intended to share personal experiences and my personal opinion of what I have learned over the years in the beauty industry and through classes and continuing education. I am not a doctor, medical professional or nutrition professional, and do not provide medical advice. Readers are advised to do their own research and make their own decisions. If you are pregnant, nursing, have a medical condition or are taking any medication, please consult your doctor before adopting my personal opinions on skin care or health.

FDA Disclaimer: The advice & statements on this blog have not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration. Any information on this website is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.








75 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page